Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Scarlett reviews the Cider House Rules

The Cider House RulesThe Cider House Rules by John Irving
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

The Cider House Rules by John Irving provides insight into the painful, politically charged, topic of abortion. Homer, an abandoned orphan, is the champion of life and finds the idea of abortion repugnant. Wilbur, the surgeon Homer considers father and mentor, feels passionately that a woman must have the right to choose. Each man sways us.

The emotional devastation wrought by the abandonment of unwanted children is sensitively told. We imagine the orphans waiting for adoptive parents, listening for the sound of cars in the lane…hoping, crying when other children are adopted. We feel Wilbur’s pain as he remembers patients dying in anguish from sepsis after tortuous attempted abortions from unskilled charlatans.

Irving crafts a human story, beautifully told, of ordinary people confronted by difficult decisions. He presents the perspectives of women caught in situations beyond their control, making it difficult for the reader to remain neutral on the subject. We are drawn in, slipping on the razor’s edge of the moral question of abortion as Candy, Grace, Lorna and Rose Rose tell their tales. We consider our view on abortion as we examine their predicaments. Is abortion, regardless of any circumstance, murder? Is it cruel to create unwanted orphans that are likely to be neglected and abused rather than to abort a fetus? Should a woman have sovereignty over her body? Irving seems to be asking us to consider these questions, and more.

When faced with unwanted pregnancy, a woman chooses her rules according to her moral or religious code. The reader may not condone abortion but, after reading this book, must acknowledge that the decision to abort is not always an act of irresponsibly selfish women choosing a frivolous method of birth control.

View all my reviews


  1. Thank you fro this review, Scarlett. Cider House Rules has been on my bookshelf for awhile. I've been meaning to get to it. And I love Irving's work. Your words make me wonder why I've taken so long. Then I glance over at my shelf and see the pile of other must reads. I don't know whether to feel blessed or frustrated that I'm such a slow, careful reader. : )

    1. Hi Leanne. How are you? I know what you mean about being swamped. I am just now in the process of updating my 'Upcoming Reviews' widget on this page. It is so tough to keep up on things, isn't it? I'm making it my goal to really try to review each book I read...and I take my time too. You can't be too careful. :-)